Index

 03 December 2006

 
Bank Mandiri to appeal in Timor case
Jakarta

Bank Mandiri is to appeal a court ruling ordering it to pay out Rp 1.02 trillion (US$112 million) to PT Timor Putra Nasional, arguing that the money should remain frozen until such time as Timor repays its debts to the bank.

The appeal will be brought in tandem with other legal efforts being made the Finance Ministry in the same case, Mandiri president Agus D. Martowardojo said.

"Mandiri will definitely file an appeal. Our lawyers are on the case," Agus was quoted by Antara as saying Friday.

"Safeguard the money, the Finance Ministry has told us, so an appeal it is."

The Finance Ministry's secretary-general, Mulia P. Nasution, had previously said the government would pursue all possible legal recourses to overturn the ruling.

The Timor case goes back to 1997 when the government appointed the company -- owned by former president Suharto's son, Hutomo Mandala Putra -- to import completely-built-up sedans from South Korea's Kia Motors, and simply rebrand them as Indonesian products to prove that the country could establish its own automotive industry, producing a so-called "national car" along the lines of Proton in Malaysia.

The Asian financial crisis that year, however, led to Timor being strangled by cash flow problems. As a result, it was unable to pay its taxes and import duties. In two operations, the first in July 2001 and second in December 2003, the Finance Ministry's Directorate General of Taxation seized Timor's assets and funds deposited in a number of banks that later merged to form Mandiri.

Timor filed a countersuit against the tax office, and was rewarded by a July 2004 Supreme Court ruling in its favor, ordering that the seized assets be restored to the company.

After Mandiri refused to return the Rp 1.02 trillion, Timor brought an action in the South Jakarta District Court, which ruled against Mandiri on Nov. 21, ordering the bank to repay the money to Timor.

Both the Finance Ministry and Mandiri have objected to the court rulings, arguing that the funds should remain frozen pending the repayment of Timor's outstanding debts to Mandiri. Agus, however, did not specify exactly how much Timor still owed Mandiri.

Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) Anwar Nasution recently said that his agency was ready to launch an audit in connection with the case, while the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) has said it has also commenced an investigation for indications of graft. There have been no updates yet on either of these efforts.

Meanwhile, State Minister for State Enterprises Sugiharto said the dispute between Timor and Mandiri should be resolved in the courts, and he was awaiting a report on the matter from Mandiri.

Separately, Mandiri chief financial officer Pahala N. Mansury was quoted by Bloomberg as saying that Indonesia's largest lender by assets would auction some Rp 15 trillion of bad loans owed by small borrowers by 2008 to help reduce delinquent debt and increase profit.

Mandiri plans to sell Rp 3 trillion of debt from borrowers who owe less than Rp 300 billion in the first half of next year, Pahala said.

With this, Mandiri expects its net non-performing loan (NPL) ratio to further decline to 5 percent by the end of 2007, after improving to 14.33 percent at the end of 2006's third quarter from 15 percent at the end of June.

The bank, with Rp 51.7 trillion of non-performing loans, also hopes to sign revamp agreements with three of its biggest debtors next month.

The lender is working with some of its debtors to reorganize their bad loans, including PT Raja Garuda Mas Group, a pulp and paper maker owned by the country's richest man, the Argo Manunggal Group and the Domba Mas Group. About 51 percent of the Jakarta-based lender's bad loans are with 30 debtors.

[Main Page] [Client Needs] [Country Focus] [Financial Services]
[Confidentiality] [Management Team] [Information System]
[Site Map] [Contact Us]

 

PT Corfina Mitrakreasi
Menara Kebon Sirih 21st Floor, Jl. Kebon Sirih 17-19
Jakarta 1034, INDONESIA
Tel:(62-21) 392-2401  |  Fax:(62-21) 392-2403
e-mail: marketing@corfina.com